logo-gold-maxim-atanassov

Risk Appetite: Definition, Statement Example and Framework

Maxim Atanassov •

Risk appetite is the amount and type of risk an organization is willing to take to achieve its objectives. The board sets it, management works within it, and a written risk appetite statement turns it into limits people can apply. Without one, every manager decides alone how much risk is too much.

The standard definitions

The main frameworks agree on the idea and differ only in wording.

SourceDefinition of risk appetite
ISO 31000 (definition in ISO 31073:2022)"Amount and type of risk that an organization is willing to pursue or retain"
COSO, Enterprise Risk Management: Integrating with Strategy and Performance (2017)"The types and amount of risk, on a broad level, an organization is willing to accept in pursuit of value"
Institute of Risk Management (IRM)"The amount and type of risk that an organisation is willing to take in order to meet their strategic objectives"
Financial Stability Board, Principles for an Effective Risk Appetite Framework (2013)"The aggregate level and types of risk a financial institution is willing to assume within its risk capacity"

Two words matter in every version: amount and type. An organization can be hungry for one kind of risk and averse to another. A software company may take large bets on new products and accept no risk at all of a privacy breach.

Risk appetite vs. risk tolerance vs. risk capacity

The three terms describe different things.

TermQuestion it answersSet byExample
Risk capacityHow much risk can we survive?The balance sheet, liquidity and regulationWe would breach our loan covenants after a loss of $20 million
Risk appetiteHow much risk do we want to take?The boardWe accept losses of up to $5 million a year in pursuit of growth
Risk toleranceHow far can a result vary before we act?Management, within the appetiteGross margin may fall to 32% against a 35% target; below that we escalate

Capacity is the ceiling. Appetite sits below it, by choice. Tolerance translates appetite into ranges around each objective. The Financial Stability Board defines risk capacity as "the maximum level of risk the financial institution can assume given its current level of resources"; an appetite set above capacity is a plan to fail.

For a full treatment of tolerance, see our guide to risk tolerance.

The five levels of risk appetite

Many organizations rate their appetite for each category of risk on a five-level scale:

LevelMeaningTypical use
AverseAvoid the risk entirelySafety, fraud, sanctions
MinimalAccept only the lowest-risk optionsRegulatory compliance, financial reporting
CautiousPrefer safe options with limited rewardLiquidity, data privacy
OpenAccept risk for a fair rewardOperations, technology change
HungrySeek risk for a high rewardInnovation, market expansion

The scale is a starting point. It becomes useful only when each level is tied to a measure, as in the example below.

What a risk appetite statement looks like

A risk appetite statement has two layers: a short narrative the board approves, and a table of measures and limits management monitors.

The statement below is illustrative, written for a fictional mid-sized Canadian manufacturer. Adapt the categories, measures and limits to your own organization.

Risk appetite statement (illustrative)

We take measured risk to grow. We will invest in new products and markets where the expected return justifies the risk, and we accept that some of these investments will fail. We will not compromise the safety of our people, the integrity of our financial reporting or our compliance with the law.
Risk categoryAppetiteMeasureLimit (escalate to the board)
Strategic: new products and marketsHungryShare of capital invested in initiatives under three years oldUp to 25%
Financial: liquidityCautiousDays of cash on handNo fewer than 60
Financial: leverageCautiousNet debt to EBITDANo more than 2.5 times
Operational: supply chainOpenRevenue dependent on a single supplierNo more than 15%
Technology: cyber securityMinimalCritical vulnerabilities open more than 30 daysZero
Health and safetyAverseLost-time injuriesZero tolerance; every incident reported to the board
ComplianceAverseMaterial regulatory breachesZero

Each row names a category, a level, a measure and a limit. A statement that stops at the narrative cannot be monitored, and a statement nobody can monitor does not change a single decision.

How to set your risk appetite in six steps

1. Start from the strategy

List the strategic objectives for the next three to five years. Appetite exists to serve them; a growth strategy with an averse appetite is a contradiction the board must resolve.

2. Measure your capacity

Work out how much loss, volatility and disruption the organization can absorb: capital, liquidity, covenants, regulatory minimums and reputation.

3. Choose the categories

Use the categories in your risk register, usually strategic, financial, operational, technology, compliance and people. Keep the list short enough for the board to debate.

4. Set a level and a measure for each

Agree on a level from the five-level scale, then pick one or two measures per category with a limit. Use the key risk indicators (KRIs) management already reports wherever possible.

5. Have the board approve it

The board owns risk appetite. The Financial Stability Board's principles state that the board approves the risk appetite statement, and observe that boards which approve it understand the organization's appetite better than boards which only receive it.

6. Monitor, escalate and review

Report each measure against its limit at every board or risk committee meeting. Define in advance what happens on a breach: who is told, how fast, and who decides the response. Review the statement every year, and whenever the strategy changes.

Common mistakes

  • Writing a statement nobody can measure. "We have a low appetite for reputational risk" is a sentiment. Name the measure.
  • Setting appetite above capacity. The appetite must leave a margin below the point where the organization fails.
  • One appetite for everything. A single level across all risks hides the trade-offs the board should make.
  • No breach process. A limit without a consequence is a suggestion.
  • Approving it and filing it. If the statement is not used in investment, budget and hiring decisions, it is not your risk appetite. Your decisions are.

Frequently asked questions

What does "risk appetite" mean?

It is the amount and type of risk an organization is willing to take to achieve its objectives.

What is an example of a risk appetite statement?

"We will not compromise the safety of our people, and we accept no material regulatory breaches. We accept measured risk in new products and markets, investing up to 25% of our capital in initiatives under three years old." A full statement adds a measure and a limit for each category of risk, as in the table above.

What are the five levels of risk appetite?

A common scale runs from averse, through minimal, cautious and open, to hungry.

Who approves the risk appetite statement?

The board of directors, usually on the recommendation of the risk or audit committee. Management proposes it and works within it.

What is a risk appetite framework?

The policies, processes, controls and systems through which the organization sets, communicates and monitors its risk appetite. The statement is the core document of the framework.

How often should risk appetite be reviewed?

At least once a year, and whenever the strategy, the capital position or the regulatory environment changes.

Further reading

Share

Maxim Atanassov

Maxim Atanassov, CPA-CA

Serial entrepreneur, tech founder, investor with a passion to support founders who are hell-bent on defining the future!

I love business. I love building companies. I co-founded my first company in my 3rd year of university. I have failed and I have succeeded. And it is that collection of lived experiences that helps me navigate the scale up journey.

I have found 4 companies to date that are scaling rapidly.